Alan Moore: The Roundtable Discussion

@SteveTrevor2.0 @NUEXGUY @Green.Lantern @discordia57 @TheSandmanofGotham @RexRebel @Clonegeek18 @MiscellaneousSoup @TheRealDetectiveChimp @CaptainYesterday
New question and WAL info below

6 Likes

@zontarr.26192 @mrsteamer96 new question above and WAL info below

5 Likes

A WAL where the idea is watch along with other people the same program at the same time and make witty remarks. Also “that’s so cool” is an accepted response.

9 Likes

Who’s art on that? Looks very cool.

8 Likes

Not my number 1 recommendation, but check the links at the top of the thread for a two issue Vigilante story by Moore. Nice solid story.

7 Likes

Travis Charest.

I sold my copy of that book years ago, but…I have a bead on where I can get a new copy and for cheap.

I hope that one day his run gets the digital treatment. It was easily the best WildC.A.T.S run ever (no offense to Grant Morrison and Jim Lee’s one-issue run).

7 Likes

Will do thanks cap. Sorry, your icon & background made that sentence come out. lol.

8 Likes

I saw it opening day & I only include that b/c it’s my #1 DC live action movie ever. So everything that’s came b4 or since hasn’t topped it for me? The shows amazing too!!!

10 Likes

Super easy question for me.

The thing I like best about League is that it contains potentially every single character I’ve read and loved in other books. I am actually shocked at how many popped up that I knew. It isn’t the first team-up of characters from literature, but I feel it is the best and definitely the most thorough. It’s so thorough so it requires commentaries to make sure you get all of the obscure references, yet the story is so good that you don’t need to dig that deep unless you want to (and yes, I want to).

Volume II is my favorite because of the Martian issue with John Carter. So cool.

@scoop001 I am excited for you getting to read this for the first time. I really hope you love it as much as I do.

12 Likes

As to best
(Besides the above)

I just reread
Promethea 1

That is a great comic
With a stunning setup
All in one issue

And
In a non linear narrative

First Alexandria Egypt
With the name drop of
Hypathia

Her death was horrific

And considerably toned
Down in the movie
Hard to watch

Then
In the present
But not our present

An alternate world
As Moore gives us clues
That this is so

With a college student
Trying to do
A paper on
Promethea

Whose names
Keeps appearing
Through the centuries

An ideal point of view
Character
For exposition

I remember
Reading the series
And I think it went
Well for many issues

Tom Strong was good too

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
Held well for two volumes
Until Moore
Decided in
Subsequent volumes
That
Storytelling
And narrative
Were not to be
The main features
Of this series

The trailer
For From Hell
Says
That Jack the Ripper
Created the 20th century.

Today
Mass violence
Can occur
In a movie theater
A super market
A primary school
Anywhere

Jack
Killed a small number of ladies of the night
No other types

The public
Was never in danger

Yet some
Say
It almost brought
Down both
Royalty and the government

Why?

Mass media was possible with
Invention of the telegram

Papers competed for sensational stories

People were uprooted
From their land
By the
Industrial Revolution
And thrown into the city

Socialism was at its height.

The Police seemed useless

The Prince of Wales
The next king
Was scandalous

But if you try
To read the phone book
I don’t think
He really shows us that time

I tried to reread it and failed.

As for
V for Vandetta

Evie stays with V
After being tortured by him?

No way

There were too many characters

Often I didn’t know who they were

The Leader?
How did he become so?
It is not shown.

The scary thing
About Thatcher
Was that she was effective

None of the forces
Allied against V
Seemed to be that.

The Valerie sequence is
Quite effective though

9 Likes

I’m on 18 for Promethea. It is a very dialogue or narrative dense book. And the language is not always straightforward or the topic simply explained, so they take time to read. About the last three issues I read were just beautiful. That’s the word I have to use. This is partly based on where I am and what I’ve experienced so maybe it won’t hit the next reader the same way.
Also, the books look amazing.

9 Likes

Alan Moore favorites roughly in order

Watchmen
Superman Annual #11 “For the Man Who Has Everything”
Superman #423/ Action Comics #583 “Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow”
Top 10 (including Smax and the 49ers GN)
Tom Strong (including Terrific Tales and Tesla Strong)
Supreme
Jack B Quick (I’m splitting up the Tomorrow Stories features)
1963
Promethea
Green Lantern #188 “Mogo Doesn’t Socialize”
Killing Joke
DC Comics Presents #85 “The Jungle Line”
Batman Annual #11 “Mortal Clay”
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (books 1 and 2 only, I haven’t read the rest)
Greyshirt
Star Wars UK Weekly
Secret Origins #10 “Phantom Stranger: Footsteps”
Spawn #8
Cobweb
First American
Terra Obscura
Green Arrow feature in Detective Comics #549-550 “Night Olympics”
Splash Brannigan

not read
V For Vendetta
Swamp Thing
From Hell
anything else not listed above

If my research is right, my last Alan Moore comic was Tom Strong #36 in 2006

the story title… “At the End of the World”

10 Likes

The movie is on peacock, think I’ll watch it sometime next week.:grinning:

8 Likes

My recommendation is Top 10, available here on DCUI. The work and people of one police station in a world populated by superheroes. I know others have successfully done the world with powers, and have done cops in a world with powers before and since, but no one has done it better. Love the humor, character work, criminal investigations and art work. And, you can spend hours scouring the backgrounds for easter eggs beyond counting. My favorite appearance is a Charlie Brown Doctor Doom child.

9 Likes

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, a great story set in the past with all the great literature characters, that I read about as a youth, perhaps not as exciting for those under 30, as they probably read or consumed different media formats. Just like, I always enjoyed Tarzan, John Carter and Conan adaptions.

6 Likes

My favorites are the ultramice and the rubbernecking gag.

6 Likes

We need an ultramice series. The result of the subplot is so meta-comics cool/funny.

6 Likes

As the moderator at the table, I believe it is incumbent upon me to note that the Roundtable has determined a Watchmen Babies and an Ultramice series are essential projects.

9 Likes

I just read the first cycle of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen on Comixology. I liked it a lot.

8 Likes

You have no idea the disappointment I had when I realized it wasn’t any of these Top 10 books.
image
image
image
image
image

7 Likes