In DETECTIVE COMICS #38, Robin was hailed as “The Sensational Character Find of 1940.” But who held that title for every other year of DC Comics? Here are my proposals, which I’ll add to over time. If you have any nominees, I’ll hear them!
1935: Dr. Occult
1936: Pep Morgan
1937: Slam Bradley
1938: Superman
1939: Batman
1940: Robin
1941: Wonder Woman
1942: Two-Face
1943: Alfred Pennyworth
1944; Solomon Grundy
1945: Black Adam
1946: Crazy Quilt
1947: Black Canary
1948: Riddler
1949: Ohiyesa Smith
1950: Lana Lang
1951: Captain Comet
1952: Phantom Stranger
1953: Angle Man
1954: Space Cabbie
1955: Martian Manhunter
1956: Barry Allen
1957: Captain Cold
1958: Saturn Girl
1959: Hal Jordan
1960: Aqualad
1961: Ray Palmer
1962: Ultra Boy
1963: Mera
1964: Zatanna
1965: Donna Troy
1966: Poison Ivy
1967: Barbara Gordon
1968: Guy Gardner
1969: Abel
1970: Darkseid
1971: John Stewart
1972: Swamp Thing
1973: Wildfire
1974: Harvey Bullock
1975: Warlord
1976: Power Girl
1977: Black Lightning
1978: Firestorm
1979: Fire
1980: Cyborg
1981: Vixen
1982: Terra
1983: Jason Todd
1984: Jericho
1985: John Constantine
1986: Booster Gold
1987: Captain Atom
1988: Ice
1989: Tim Drake
1990: Hank Henshaw
Between writing that post and now I read the Punchline Special, which may have changed my mind. Point is, Tynion’s really on a tear, isn’t he?
Also, for 1936, hear me out:
Pandora
Yeah, I know, she’s an adaptation of a character from an earlier mythology, but 70-some years later she would be the story explanation for the origin of the New 52, appear in all 52 #1 issues, get her own book, and be the focal point of Trinity War.