Stargirl Casting

Just saw the premier and loved it. My only complaint is using Joel McHale as Sylvester Pemberton/Starman. Joel has too much personality for that role, and to be making minor appearances. DCU needs to cast that man as Booster Gold!

1 Like

You’re assuming he wants to do that. Some actors aren’t interested in big Blockbuster roles like that because of the pressures, invasions of privacy, and lack of a normal life. We also have no clue what kind of a role the JSA and Starman will play. We’re one episode in. So, who knows how much he’ll be in the show.

Obviously, I would love Joel McHale as Booster Gold or something like that. But I’m not gonna say it was bad casting (especially on a show like this whose casting overall I think is very stellar).