Some concept art of Tom Welling as Kingdom Come Superman.
I prefer this over Routh
We all do
Honestly them having Routh do the role seems to be more cost-saving than anything. I’d personally rather have Welling just because he did the role for 10 seasons compared to someone who only did it for one movie, but what can you do?
Brandon greater than Tom?
One played, not his own version but a copy of Chris Reeves, for two hours.
The other played his own version for ten years.
Stop making me defend Smallville
Yes to your question
Routh had an unsuccessful superman movie…
Welling had 10 years but became a very disappointing CGI superman… So… Idk!!