Batman: The Audio Adventures has me wondering how many SNL cast members have played roles in DC productions before, so I’ve made a list. In cases where players have portrayed multiple roles, I’ve pared it down to their most significant. Let me know if I’ve missed anybody!
(This list goes out to @JayleighJayeJimenez, DC and television super-fan, who’s been having a pretty hard time this week. Hope you feel better soon.)
Laraine Newman (1975-1980):
- Toby Raynes (Superman: The Animated Series)
- Baby-Doll (The New Batman Adventures)
- Medusa (Justice League Unlimited)
- Miss Minerva (Batman: The Brave and the Bold)
Gilbert Gottfried (1980-1981):
- Nick Nack (Superboy)
- Mr. Mxyzptlk (Superman: The Animated Series)
Laurie Metcalf (1981):
- Mary McGowan (Supergirl, “Schott Through the Heart”)
Gary Kroeger (1982-1985):
- Beechum (Batman: The Animated Series, “Paging the Crime Doctor”)
Pamela Stephenson (1984-1985):
- Lorelei Ambrosia (Superman III)
Nora Dunn (1985-1990):
- Oona (DMZ)
Jon Lovitz (1985-1990):
- Sid Sharp (Justice League Action, “Superman’s Pal, Sid Sharp”)
Tim Meadows (1991-2000):
- Jeremiah Arkham (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Laura Kightlinger (1994-1995):
- Orca (The LEGO Batman Movie)
Michael McKean (1994-1995):
- Silver Age Joker (The New Batman Adventures, “Legends of the Dark Knight”)
- Sportsman (Justice League, “Legends”)
- Perry White (Smallville)
- Dr. Bartholomew Wolper (Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Pts. 1 & 2)
Chris Parnell (1998-2006):
- Narrator (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Rachel Dratch (1999-2006):
- Negative Woman (Teen Titans Go!)
- Nora Fries (Harley Quinn)
Seth Meyers (2001-2014):
- Jack Ryder (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Fred Armisen (2002-2013):
- King Scimitar (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Kenan Thompson (2003-Present):
- Commissioner Gordon (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Kristen Wiig (2005-2012):
- Cheetah (Wonder Woman 1984)
Jason Sudeikis (2005-2013):
- Mayor Hamilton Hill (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Bobby Moynihan (2008-2017):
- The Penguin (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Jenny Slate (2009-2010):
- Harley Quinn (The LEGO Batman Movie)
Vanessa Bayer (2010-2017):
- PB the Wonder-Pig (League of Super-Pets)
Kate McKinnon (2012-2022):
- Lulu (League of Super-Pets)
Kyle Mooney (2013-2022):
- Michelangelo (Batman vs. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles)
Pete Davidson (2014-2022):
- Blackguard (The Suicide Squad)
Melissa Villaseñor (2016-2022):
- Dick Grayson (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
Heidi Gardner (2017-Present):
- Miss Tuesday (Batman: The Audio Adventures)
- Dr. Harleen Quinzel (Batman: The Audio Adventures, Season 1)
Who else from the SNL cast and history would fit somewhere in the DC Universe, and who would you cast them as?