Comic Review - Curse of the White Knight

The End of Days has come for Batman. A higher power has dispatched an angel of death of vengeance against the Dark Knight. Gotham’s protector will be put through a trial by fire in this follow-up to Sean Murphy’s original story. Bruce will find out secrets that will shake him to his core, and affect how he sees himself and his family. Amid the shocking revelations, change will come that will force Gotham to adapt to the harsh road laid before it. Azrael is here and nothing will be the same.

It would be easy to say that Curse of the White Knight is a repeat of its predecessor. Both books have big overlaps in terms of the themes it talks about. The biggest overlap is in recognizing the full consequences of one’s actions and trying to find a better way. But as I looked back on this book in preparation for my review, I found that this sequel actually presents ideas that serve as a natural progression of the original comic. It is easy to say that things need to change. Admitting that is only the first step towards true progress. If you truly seek growth and change, you will most likely be forced to make some tough choices. And the fallout of those choices can seem overwhelming. If you are serious about what you say, then you may have to make a hard sacrifice. At the end of the original story, Batman reveals his identity to James Gordon and at the beginning of this story, he plans on ultimately revealing his identity to all of Gotham. It takes one of the villains of this story to spell out what exactly that would mean for Bruce if he follows through.

Screenshot 2023-05-12 8.17.01 PM

A lot of the revelations that are exposed in this comic serve to progress the themes of The White Knight. Do you want to change how Gotham works? Turns out, it was designed this way from its conception. In order to take on the challenge of breaking the cycle, you must understand how it started. As it turns out, this is tied a lot to the history of the Wayne Family and how Gotham came to be. And we see a lot of parallels to how similar situations played out in our real world. People from different cultures join together with the promise to share power and land equally only for one to betray the other and create everything in their image, often finding ways to profit off what they establish. The struggle between Batman and Azrael becomes more than just a pawn fighting a hero, but rather the descendant of the betrayed seeking retribution for the sins of the past.

This brings up the question of how we should react and respond to the actions of our ancestors. Do we simply try and improve existing institutions and laws? Do we pay reparations to the people that have suffered the most from past actions? Or do we take the scorched Earth approach and tear down everything? I want to share a scene that’s a confrontation between Batman and Azrael and examine it from a couple of different perspectives.

Let’s start with the more literal interpretation. Both of these characters have been shaped by their ancestors to some extent. Both of them are admittedly very similar to the other. Azrael admits as much when he talks about how people like Bruce are plentiful from his walk of life. Soldiers and fighters are willing to do what it takes to defend their ideals and/or their way of life. As Batman points out the obvious difference that he doesn’t kill, Azrael criticizes him for not going all the way and therefore never truly affecting anything. This actually ties in a lot to my observations of Batman based on The White Knight, how Bruce’s narrow view of how to bring change and make a difference either does nothing or oftentimes makes it worse. All he is doing is dragging things out instead of biting the bullet and doing something truly impactful.

Now, the more metaphorical interpretation. There are a lot of people in the real world who talk about helping others and making a difference. Often involving donating money or goods to those in poorer nations. Maybe establishing a charity to more directly help certain communities. But that only does so much. There are institutions - corporations and governments - that will end up protecting the status quo at the end of the day. Not doing anything too significant that might affect how they live their lives. Allowing the elite to become more powerful while everybody else is exploited and discarded. Bruce’s refusal to kill can be interpreted as someone with the means to go against these institutions as his refusal of giving up his way of life. And by doing so, proof that he’ll never be able to help anyone.

And Azrael is right. Bruce is willing to admit it, just as he was willing to admit that Napier was right before. As the comic approaches the final fight, he sends his message out to the people about how he was wrong to view himself as heroic as he used to and pledges to bring real change.

Screenshot 2023-05-13 8.42.56 AM
Screenshot 2023-05-13 8.43.20 AM

Following the climax, those changes do indeed happen. Gotham seems to be heading down the right path. But there are plenty of questions and issues that will still need to be dealt with as the people move forward.

The criticisms regarding police militarization and not doing enough go hand in hand. Some slack can be given regarding upgrading the police because this is a superhero universe. However, most of the villains we used to know have been killed off by Azrael. So an argument can be made that further upgrades to the police aren’t necessary. While other methods of community outreach such as mental care and social programs are more in need of that funding and drive. The criticism of Socialism is a bit tricky. Considering what has been revealed about the Batman Devastation Fund and the history of Gotham, one can argue that Capitalism is responsible for a lot of problems this world is forced to deal with. This parallels a lot of real-world arguments regarding the flaws and corruption associated with Capitalism and how the people at the top benefit from it. Obviously, my amateur review of a comic book story isn’t the right place to debate Capitalism versus Socialism. But the fact that it is being brought up in this comic is proof that communication is opening up and people can finally start working together as opposed to a small group making decisions behind closed doors. We all need to reckon with the past and understand it, be willing to talk about it if we are to come up with solutions for our current problems.

This ended up being shorter than I anticipated mainly because there is a lot of overlap between this comic and its predecessor. But Curse of the White Knight is also a natural progression and deeper exploration that introduces more complex questions when dealing with the aftermath of hard choices. It can be hard to deal with the fallout, this story shows just as much. However, forgiveness is there for those that take the right steps.

1 Like

Ah Batman and Politics. I might get into this discussion further with the Future State Batman in the Batman trend, but what I found interesting about Batman being a social justice warrior. The traditional meaning, not a derogative word made by the notorious bad faith individuals of the world. Batman is probably from my standpoint progressive. You see a progressive works within the system to make it a better place through reform or non-profits. Socialist seek to dissolve or even remove the many capitalist characteristics to make it a more collective responsibility on a city like Gotham to manage.
He may not be socialist, despite this series coming close to one, but he’s still paving Gotham in futher preventing more criminals than before by providing more for the currently struggling with funding education and homeless shelters. So that in of itself is good overall, but you might understand when some people say he didn’t go futher.

I like how Azrael and Jack Napier much like Killmonger from Black Panther actually changed Batman to be a better hero. A good Villain is someone who makes the hero actually consider his approach rather than doubling down on his flaws.

I always wonder if Bruce Batman ever became a public superhero he would do similar things in the mainline books. I think he can, but much like Superman. A lot of writers and editors are just more comfortable in the status quo.

Great review @EDT. Very insightful.

1 Like

It would be very interesting to see main universe Batman be public. Unfortunately, comics have gotten into saying they are changing the status quo but either don’t full commit or revert back after a short while.

Best examples I can think of are when Superman revealed his identity only for Luthor to wipe out that information from the world and when Dark Crisis teased the deaths of major heroes only for all of them to come back to life

1 Like

Sean Murphy and what he has done with the White Knight series is just mind blowing, the art , forgetaboudit! each panel packs so much .

For me the big surprises that came up in this first round of White Knight, was something I could live with as a fan of Batman, for one because I knew it wasn’t going to be cannon, but 2 because, I don’t look at Bruce Wayne being someone who is defined by his wealth, he is going to be Batman with or with out the prestige of wealth or an upper class life. He is passionate about helping others.

Now, to compare this to the Batman story Fortress, where Superman is just missing while bad guys are after him. I see a comparison in that , in the end of Fortress, Superman has to come to terms with his family history on Krypton, and he does what he feels is the right thing. On one hand I look at what Superman did , in Fortress, as just giving up. He gave up a purpose and passed it on to who, the only person he could trust, Bruce Wayne.

Where as compare it to White Knight, Bruce finds out some ugly truths, and he deals with it. I have to re-read White Knight because I am almost certain, that Bruce, just isn’t phased at all by what he finds out. From what I recall it came off as okay, well, that sucks but I gotta deal with Gotham and what is infront of me.