Best Episode Tournament: Batman The Animated Series

[TheBatgirlofNML]

Interested to see what the final results are!

[MatthewHecht]

Normally on polls “Almost Got Em’” comes in first place. “Trial” and "Heart of “Ice” normally compete for that spot.

[TheBatgirlofNML]

My personal vote is Heart of Ice tied with See No Evil.

[staticshocks]

I don’t think my fave made the list, but it’s definitely “Beware the Creeper”. I have “yellow-skinned whacky man” stuck in my head way too often

[bookwormfitzpatrick.91230]

Same here!

[staticshocks]

Yellow skinned wacky man

This has been stuck in my head at least once a week for the past FOURTEEN YEARS

[TheBatgirlofNML]

That’s also my favorite! I loved Jeff Bennet’s Creeper. Plus Question had a cameo of you watch closely.

[BatMike-ThePunisher]

There are so many BTAS episodes.

[MatthewHecht]

Is this a bad time to say I never liked that episode?

I never liked that episode.

[Reaganfan78]

Love the episode, but technically it’s The New Batman Adventures and not Batman The Animated Series, that’s why I didn’t add them to the tournament, I’ll try to remember to make a tournament for it later this year.
Thankyou so much everybody for making this tournament a hit, some of the voting actually suprise me, love it!

[Reaganfan78]

Hello everybody,
Here’s a winners for the first round for Best Episode of Batman The Animated Series…

Round 1 Winners
Cat & The Claw Part 1 & 2
Heart Of Ice
Joker’s Favor
Nothing To Fear
Appointment In Crime Alley
The Clock King
The Last Laugh
Two-Face Part 1 & 2
I’ve Got Batman In My Basement
The Forgotten
Mad As A Hatter
Perchance To Dream
The Strange Secret Of Bruce Wayne
Dreams In Darkness
Beware Of The Grey Ghost
Almost Got’em
Terror In The Sky
Christmas With The Joker
If You’re So Smart, Why Aren’t You Rich?
His Silicon Soul
The Laughing Fish
Harley & Ivy
The Man Who Killed Batman
Robin’s Reckoning Part 1 & 2
Blind As A Bat
The Demon’s Quest Part 1 & 2
Read My Lips
Shadow Of The Bat Part 1 & 2
Paging The Crime Doctor
House & Garden
Trial
Harlequinade
Riddler’s Reform
Baby-Doll
Harley’s Holiday
Batgirl Returns
Deep Freeze
Showdown
A Bullet For Bullock

These are the winners so far, Round 2 will be coming soon. Thankyou so much for voting.

[Reaganfan78]

Round 2 Part 1

• Cat & The Claw Part 1 & 2
• Heart Of Ice

• Joker’s Favor
• Nothing To Fear

• Appointment In Crime Alley
• The Clock King

• The Last Laugh
• Two-Face Part 1 & 2

• I’ve Got Batman In My Basement
• The Forgotten

• Mad As A Hatter
• Perchance To Dream

• The Strange Secret Of Bruce Wayne
• Dream In Darkness

• Beware The Grey Ghost
• Almost Got’em

• Terror In The Sky
• Christmas With The Joker

• If You’re So Smart, Why Aren’t You Rich?
• His Silicon Soul

• The Laughing Fish
• Harley & Ivy

[MatthewHecht]

@Reaganfan78

• 50%Dream In Darkness

• 

• 50%The Strange Secret Of Bruce Wayne

• 

That was the hardest one.

Interesting fact: Joel Shumacker’s third Batman movie was supposed to be an adaptation of that episode. They had Nicholson ready to reprise his role as a nightmare, Harley Quinn would be in it as the secondary villain reinterpeted to be Joker’s daughter out for revenge, and Scarecrow would be the main villain.

[Reaganfan78]

Round 2 Part 2:

• The Man Who Killed Batman
• Robin’s Reckoning Part 1 & 2

• Blind As A Bat
• Demon’s Quest Part 1 & 2

• Read My Lips
• Shadow Of The Bat Part 1 & 2

• Paging The Crime Doctor
• House And Garden

• Trial
• Harlequinade

• Riddler’s Reform
• Baby-Doll

• Harley’s Holiday
• Batgirl Returns

• Deep Freeze
• Showdown
• A Bullet For Bullock

That’s it, The last poll will have 2 winners to even the poll for round 3, whatever episode has less percentage lose.

[MatthewHecht]

@Reaganfan78

• 100%Trial

• 

• 

• 0%Harlequinade

Hardest one.

[basicallytimdrake]

Paging The Crime Doctor/ House And Garden was the hardest vote for me to decide on

[RexRebel]

Can’t we have an option that I love them all equally.

[Reaganfan78]

Hey @HubCityQuestion, @Huntress_Helena, @Sean-Malloy, Round 2 of voting is up if you like to vote.

[Reaganfan78]

Hello everybody,
Thankyou so much for voting, here’s the list of Round 2 winners!

Round 2 Winners…
Heart Of Ice
Joker’s Favor
Appointment In Crime Alley
Two-Face Part 1 & 2
The Forgotten
Perchance To Dream
The Strange Secret Of Bruce Wayne
Almost Got’em
Christmas With The Joker
If You’re So Smart, Why Aren’t You Rich?
Harley & Ivy
The Laughing Fish
The Man Who Killed Batman
Demon’s Quest Part 1 & 2
Shadow Of The Bat Part 1 & 2
Paging The Crime Doctor
Trial
Riddler’s Reform
Harley’s Holiday
A Bullet For Bullock
Deep Freeze

We have 1 tie between Harley and Ivy & The Laughing Fish, I will have them against the last 2 episodes on the list for round 3, which makes sense for me.
I’ll have round 3 up in a few minutes.

[Reaganfan78]

Round 3 For Best Episode

• Heart Of Ice
• Joker’s Favor

• Appointment In Crime Alley
• Two-Face Part 1 & 2

• The Forgotten
• Perchance To Dream

• The Strange Secret Of Bruce Wayne
• Almost Got’em

• Christmas With The Joker
• If You’re So Smart, Why Aren’t You Rich?

• Harley & Ivy
• A Bullet For Bullock

• Trial
• Deep Freeze

• The Man Who Killed Batman
• Demon’s Quest Part 1 & 2

• Shadow Of The Bat Part 1 & 2
• Paging The Crime Doctor

• Riddler’s Reform
• Harley’s Holiday

I’ve decided to take Laughing Fish out due to being in 2nd in a tie so technicallyit did lost, and to keeping this tournament even, have fun voting and Thankyou everybody.