You pretty well took the words out of my mouth. I’m a Superman fan first and foremost. That’s pretty much all I know from the New 52 era. I absolutely love what Grant Morrison did. I really enjoyed Pak up until the whole “Truth” storyline began. Not a fan of that whole thing. I thought Johns did solid work, though not as good as he did on Supes pre-Flashpoint. Tomasi had a nice Superman/Wonder Woman arc before the “Truth” stuff and did a great job with the Final Days of Superman. The rest I don’t ever need to read again.
Got really good after#7 when it started to be more villan focused.